- Harbourfront Quantitative Newsletter
- Posts
- Herding, Anti-Herding, and Investment Performance
Herding, Anti-Herding, and Investment Performance
Measuring Herding and Its Impact on Investment Performance
Herding behavior is a common phenomenon in financial markets, where investors follow the actions of others rather than make independent decisions. But how does herding affect investment performance, and how can it be measured?
In this issue, we examine two studies that approach these questions from different perspectives.
In this issue:
Latest Posts
How Options Markets Inform Asset Allocation and Trading Strategies (10 min)
Hedge Fund Performance, Market Regimes, and Drawdown Risk (8 min)
The Role of Liquidity in Stock Returns and Option Pricing (8 min)
Correlation, Volatility-of-Volatility, and Sector Implied Volatility (10 min)
Reflexivity and the Dynamics of Option Markets (10 min)
Anti-Herding Behavior of Hedge Funds
Herding behavior is the tendency of investors to follow the actions of others rather than make independent investment decisions. It is a well-documented phenomenon in financial markets and can contribute to excessive price movements, market bubbles, and crashes. Anti-herding, on the other hand, occurs when investors deliberately take positions that differ from the market consensus.
Hedge fund managers are generally expected to develop independent trading strategies based on proprietary research and information. But do they actually exhibit anti-herding behavior, and does it lead to better investment performance? Reference [1] examines these questions using a large dataset of U.S. hedge funds.
Findings
The study examines 1,899 active, liquidated, and merged U.S. hedge funds from January 1994 to December 2020 and finds evidence of widespread anti-herding behavior among hedge fund managers.
Anti-herding is primarily driven by fundamental information, reflecting differences in managers' private information and interpretations of publicly available information.
Anti-herding persists across different market volatility and credit deterioration conditions, although funding illiquidity has a stronger influence on this behavior.
The degree of anti-herding varies across hedge fund strategies, particularly during crises. Convertible Arbitrage, Equity Market Neutral, and Fixed Income Arbitrage funds exhibited herding during the COVID-19 crisis.
Hedge funds exhibiting stronger anti-herding behavior earn statistically higher excess returns than those with weaker anti-herding, particularly over intermediate and longer horizons of up to one year.
However, greater anti-herding is also associated with higher subsequent idiosyncratic volatility, highlighting a relationship between independent trading decisions, risk, and expected returns.
In summary, the anti-herding behavior of hedge fund managers in the US has been investigated, and it appears that their behavior leads to excess returns. In a nutshell, these managers are looking to make money by going against what is popular at the time. They do not follow any trends or consensus opinions within an industry but rather focus on their own research and analysis to decide where they want to put their funds.
Reference
[1] S. Ali, I. Badshah, R. Demirer, Anti-Herding by Hedge Funds, Idiosyncratic Volatility and Expected Returns, 2022.
Measuring Stock Market Dispersion: The Herd Behavior Index Approach
Dispersion in the stock market refers to the degree of variation in individual stock returns within an index or sector. High dispersion indicates significant differences in performance among stocks. Conversely, low dispersion suggests that stocks are moving more uniformly, often driven by broad market trends.
Usually, dispersion is measured by implied correlation. Reference [2] proposed a method to measure dispersion called the Herd Behavior Index (HIX). It is calculated as the ratio of the variance of a stock index to the variance of a hypothetical index that represents the extreme case of comonotonicity or perfect herd behavior. The variance is determined using model-free methods involving options, similar to the calculation of the VIX.
Findings
The study introduces the Herd Behavior Index (HIX), a forward-looking, model-independent measure of stock market co-movement based on observed option prices.
The HIX measures the degree of herding by comparing the option-implied risk-neutral variance of a market index with its theoretical maximum variance under a comonotonic scenario, in which all constituent stocks are driven by a single factor.
The index is calculated using option prices on the market index and its constituent stocks, following an approach similar to the VIX methodology.
The HIX can be constructed for any market index with sufficiently available vanilla options on both the index and its components.
The authors illustrate the methodology by calculating the historical 30-day HIX for the Dow Jones Industrial Average from January 2003 to October 2009.
Unlike implied correlation, which measures weighted average pairwise linear correlations, the HIX/CIX captures more general forms of dependence between stock prices.
The HIX reaches its theoretical maximum of 1 if and only if the underlying variables are comonotonic, providing a direct interpretation of extreme market co-movement that implied correlation does not offer.
This is an innovative proposal, but its practical application and effectiveness remain to be seen. One can apply it, for example, to option dispersion trading. A high HIX value suggests buying individual options and selling index options. The position can then be closed when the market stabilizes and the HIX decreases. Further research is needed to assess the profitability of this strategy and the effectiveness of the Herd Behavior Index in general.
Reference
[2] Jan Dhaene, Daniël Linders, Wim Schoutens, David Vyncke, The Herd Behavior Index: A new measure for the implied degree of co-movement in stock markets, Insurance: Mathematics and Economics Volume 50, Issue 3, May 2012, Pages 357-370
Closing Thoughts
Taken together, these two studies offer different perspectives on herding behavior in financial markets. The first examines the trading behavior of hedge fund managers and finds that anti-herding is associated with higher excess returns, albeit with greater idiosyncratic volatility.
The second introduces an options-based measure of market-wide co-movement, providing a forward-looking indicator of herding behavior. Both studies highlight the importance of understanding herding dynamics for investment decisions and risk management.
Additional Reading
For further discussion on herd behavior, refer to the previous issues:
Educational Video
Herding and Bubbles (Financial Markets Microstructure), part 2
This lecture examines the mechanisms behind herding behavior and speculative bubbles in financial markets. Herding can arise from failures in information aggregation, reputation concerns, and compensation incentives. For example, investment managers may imitate their peers to protect their reputations, even when their private information suggests otherwise. Similarly, benchmark-relative compensation can encourage risk-averse managers to follow the market rather than pursue independent strategies. The lecture also explains that price adjustments can reduce information asymmetry but may not eliminate herding when uncertainty is complex. Under certain conditions, momentum trading can therefore be a rational response to market information rather than simply an irrational behavioral tendency.
The lecture then discusses the rational bubble model of Abreu and Brunnermeier (2003). In this model, sophisticated investors gradually become aware that an asset is overpriced, but they do not know when other investors received the same information. Consequently, they may rationally continue holding the asset to benefit from further price appreciation, despite anticipating an eventual collapse. The model identifies three important determinants of bubble persistence: the rate of price appreciation, the dispersion of information arrival times, and the market's capacity to absorb selling pressure. When these factors are sufficiently high, investors delay selling, and the bubble persists until an external correction occurs. Otherwise, coordinated selling can trigger an endogenous crash. The lecture also introduces sunspot equilibria, in which seemingly unrelated public events coordinate investors' selling decisions, and relates these coordination mechanisms to bank runs and currency attacks.
Around the Quantosphere
If You Can’t Measure It, You Can’t Improve It! (citadelsecurities)
Lessons from a miserable month for hedge funds (economist)
This Hedge Fund Called Out Huang’s ‘Special Relationship’ Months Ago (afr)
Hedge Funds Liquidating Equity Positions Led to Thursday’s Tech Rout (pensionpulse)
Tech Selloff Wipes Out Hedge Fund Gains, Prompting Risk Cuts and Layoffs (reuters)
Inside October’s Hedge Fund Bloodbath — and Why the Pain Might Not Be Over (businessinsider)
AI free-fall triggers another major hedge fund shakeout (finance.yahoo)
Hedge fund manager nearly blew up his firm, but knows how to keep a secret. The job interview that cost more than a billion dollars (efinancialcareers)
“From AI Growth Hopes to Fears of Financial Distress”: Wall Street Hedging Surges as Falling Stocks and Data Center Construction Delays Fuel Bubble Warnings (economy.ac)
Disclaimer
This newsletter is not investment advice. It is provided solely for entertainment and educational purposes. Always consult a financial professional before making any investment decisions.
We are not responsible for any outcomes arising from the use of the content and codes provided in the outbound links. By continuing to read this newsletter, you acknowledge and agree to this disclaimer.